How to Get Feedback From Peers (Not Just Your Manager)

To get feedback from peers, ask specific colleagues specific questions about a recent piece of work, make it easy for them to be honest, and respond with thanks rather than defense. “Any feedback?” gets polite silence. “What’s one thing I could have done to make Tuesday’s handoff easier for you?” gets something you can use.
Your manager sees only part of your work. Peers see how you collaborate, communicate, and show up day to day. This guide covers who to ask, the questions that get honest answers, a message template, and what to do with what you hear.
Key takeaways
Peer feedback fills the blind spots your manager can’t see, especially around collaboration and communication.
Specific, low-stakes questions about recent work get far more honest answers than general requests.
How you react the first time determines whether peers will be honest the next time.
Blomma, the AI career coaching platform, helps you plan who to ask, make sense of what you hear, and turn feedback into goals.
How do I ask my coworkers for feedback?
Ask your coworkers for feedback by choosing two or three people who work closely with you, asking about a specific recent project or behavior, and giving them a simple question to answer. Ask in a low-pressure way, like a quick chat or message, and tell them why you’re asking. People are more honest when they know you genuinely want it.
Follow these steps:
Pick the right people. Choose peers who’ve seen your work recently, including at least one you don’t always agree with.
Name the context. “On the Q3 launch…” is much easier to answer than “in general.”
Ask one or two focused questions. See the question bank below.
Explain why. “I’m working on running smoother handoffs this quarter.”
Give them time. Let them reply by message or in a quick chat later in the week.
Say thank you and close the loop. Tell them later what you changed.
If you’re new to a role, our guide to asking for feedback in your first weeks covers that stage.
What questions get honest feedback from peers?
Questions that get honest feedback from peers are specific, forward-looking, and make criticism feel safe to share. Ask about one thing you could do differently, not what you did wrong. “What’s one thing I could do to make working with me easier?” invites honesty without forcing anyone to sound critical.
Goal | Question to ask |
|---|---|
Collaboration | “What’s one thing I could do to make working with me easier?” |
Communication | “Were my updates on the project clear enough? What would have helped?” |
Meetings | “When I’m in meetings with you, is there anything I do that gets in the way?” |
Strengths | “What’s something I do that you’d want me to keep doing?” |
Growth | “If you were in my role, what’s one skill you’d work on next?” |
A specific moment | “How did that client call come across from your side?” |
Avoid yes-or-no questions like “Was that okay?” They make it easy to say “Yep, all good.”
A peer feedback request template
A peer feedback request template makes it easy to ask, and easy for your colleague to answer. Keep it short, name the context, ask one or two questions, and give them an easy way to respond. You can send it as a message or use it as an opener in a quick conversation.
“Hi [Name], I’m working on [specific skill] this quarter, and you’ve seen a lot of my work on [project]. Would you share one thing I did well and one thing I could do differently? A couple of sentences is perfect, and no rush. Thanks, I really appreciate it.”
The phrase “one thing… and one thing” gives a clear, limited ask, which makes people more likely to respond honestly.
How often should I ask for peer feedback?
Ask for peer feedback after any meaningful project or milestone, and aim for a light check-in with a few colleagues roughly every quarter. That’s often enough to catch patterns early without feeling like you’re constantly asking. Ask more often when you’re new, recently promoted, or working on a specific skill.
A simple rhythm:
After each major project: one or two quick questions to collaborators
Quarterly: a short check-in with two or three peers
Before your performance review: gather peer input to include in your self-review (pair it with strong career goals for your review)
What do I do with peer feedback once I have it?
Once you have peer feedback, thank the person, look for patterns across several people rather than reacting to one comment, pick one change to focus on, and tell your peers what you’re trying. Acting visibly on feedback is what makes colleagues willing to be honest again. Ignoring it, or defending yourself, shuts the door.
How to respond in the moment: “Thanks, that’s helpful. Can you give me an example?” Then pause before reacting. For more on staying open, see how to receive feedback at work.
Related guides:
How Blomma Helps
Blomma, the AI career coaching platform, helps you get more from peer feedback at every step. Plan who to ask and which questions fit your goals, draft a request that sounds like you, then talk through what you heard, especially the comments that sting. Blomma helps you spot patterns, turn feedback into a concrete goal, and checks in on your progress so the feedback leads to real change.
That’s what makes Blomma better than handling feedback alone. Unlike a notes file, Blomma helps you interpret mixed feedback and decide what to act on. Unlike a generic chatbot, it remembers your goals and past feedback, so it can show how you’re improving over time. And because conversations are private, you can be honest about how feedback landed.
Start your growth journey with Blomma →
Frequently asked questions
Why is peer feedback important if my manager already gives feedback?
Peer feedback is important because peers see different parts of your work than your manager does: how you collaborate, share information, handle disagreements, and support others. Managers often see outcomes; peers see the day-to-day behaviors behind them. Combining both gives you a much more complete picture of how you’re doing.
What if a coworker gives me feedback I disagree with?
Thank them, ask for an example, and take time before deciding what to do with it. One comment may reflect a single moment or their own perspective. If you hear similar feedback from others, it’s probably worth acting on. If not, note it and keep watching for patterns.
How do I get honest feedback from peers who are too polite?
Make criticism easier to give by asking narrow, forward-looking questions like “What’s one thing I could do differently?” Share why you’re asking, and show you can take it well by reacting with curiosity. Asking in writing can also help, because some people find it easier to be candid when they have time to think.
What’s a good tool for turning peer feedback into an action plan?
Blomma is a great option. You can bring the feedback you’ve collected to Blomma, talk through what it means, and set a specific goal based on the patterns. Blomma then checks in on your progress and remembers what you’ve been working on, so feedback turns into lasting improvement.
Should I ask peers for feedback in person or in writing?
Both work, and the best choice depends on the person and the topic. In person lets you ask follow-up questions and read tone. In writing gives people time to think and can make candor easier. A good approach is to ask in writing, then follow up briefly in person.
