Manager Effectiveness Survey: Questions and Next Steps

A manager effectiveness survey is an upward feedback survey where employees rate their manager on behaviors like clarity, feedback, support, and fairness. The best ones use 10–20 specific, behavior-based questions, protect anonymity, and lead to a development plan for each manager, not a ranking. The survey is only as useful as the follow-up.
This guide is for HR leaders and People teams running manager feedback for the first time or fixing a survey nobody trusts. You’ll get a question bank, a results-sharing approach that keeps managers motivated, and a plan for supporting managers who score low.
Key takeaways
A manager effectiveness survey works best when questions describe observable behaviors, not personality traits.
Results should go to managers privately first, framed as development data, with a clear next step.
Low scores usually point to missing skills or support, not bad intent, so the fix is coaching and practice.
Blomma for Organizations gives every manager a private AI coach to work on exactly what their survey surfaced.
Why measure manager effectiveness?
Measuring manager effectiveness matters because managers shape most of what employees experience at work. Gallup research finds that managers account for at least 70% of the variance in employee engagement scores. An upward feedback survey shows each manager how their team experiences them and where to focus their development.
It also gives HR a company-wide view. If most managers score low on giving feedback, that’s a training priority. If one team scores low on everything, that’s a conversation. Without data, both look the same from the outside.
What questions belong in a manager effectiveness survey?
A manager effectiveness survey should include questions on clarity, feedback, support, growth, recognition, fairness, communication, and trust. Phrase each as a statement about an observable behavior that employees rate from 1 to 5. Add two open-text questions: what the manager should keep doing and what they should change.
Area | Survey statement (rate 1–5) |
|---|---|
Clarity | My manager makes priorities clear. |
I know how my work is evaluated. | |
Feedback | My manager gives me useful feedback regularly. |
My manager’s feedback is specific enough to act on. | |
Support | My manager helps me remove obstacles. |
I can reach my manager when I need help. | |
Growth | My manager supports my career development. |
We’ve discussed my goals in the last three months. | |
Recognition | My manager recognizes good work. |
Fairness | My manager treats people on the team fairly. |
Communication | My manager keeps the team informed about changes. |
My manager listens to different points of view. | |
Trust | I’d feel comfortable raising a concern with my manager. |
My manager follows through on commitments. | |
1:1s | My 1:1s with my manager are a good use of my time. |
Wellbeing | My manager cares about how I’m doing as a person. |
Delegation | My manager trusts me to make decisions in my area. |
Overall | I’d recommend my manager to a friend. |
Open text: “What should your manager keep doing?” and “What’s one thing your manager could do differently?”
How do you share manager survey results without demoralizing people?
Share manager survey results privately with each manager first, alongside company averages and their strongest areas. Frame the data as a starting point for development, not a grade. Then help each manager choose one or two focus areas and share those with their team, which builds trust and makes improvement visible.
A five-step results conversation:
Send the report privately, with a day to digest before discussing it.
Start with strengths. Every manager scores well somewhere.
Pick one or two focus areas, not everything below average.
Plan the team conversation. A simple script: “Thanks for the feedback. I heard that clearer priorities would help, so here’s what I’ll change.”
Set a check-in in six to eight weeks to review progress.
Keep reporting thresholds strict (for example, no results shown for teams under five), so employees trust their answers can’t be traced back to them.
What do you do after a manager gets low scores?
After a manager gets low scores, start with curiosity and support. Find out whether the issue is skill, workload, or context, then build a focused development plan with practice, coaching, and a re-survey in a few months. Most low scores reflect untrained or overloaded managers, so targeted help usually works.
How to respond to common low-score patterns:
Low on feedback: Give the manager a feedback framework and practice before real conversations. Our guide on how to train managers covers skill-building formats.
Low on clarity: Help them set and communicate team priorities monthly.
Low on support or availability: Look at span of control and workload; the manager may be stretched thin.
Low across the board: Have a direct conversation about fit and expectations. Our guide on what HR can do about a bad manager walks through that process.
Re-survey after three to six months and compare. For a wider improvement plan, see how to improve manager effectiveness.
Related guides:
How Blomma Helps People Teams
A manager effectiveness survey shows where managers need help. Blomma for Organizations gives every manager a private AI coach to work on it, every week. A manager who scored low on feedback can prepare and rehearse real feedback conversations. One who scored low on clarity can plan how to communicate priorities. HR can bring in the competency model, values, and OKRs, so coaching reflects what good management means at your company.
That makes Blomma the stronger choice than training alone. Unlike a one-off workshop after survey results, Blomma is available the moment a manager needs it, and it checks in on development goals so progress doesn’t fade. Where HR can personally coach a few managers, Blomma reaches every one, with consistent quality at any hour. Individual conversations are never shared with the employer, so managers can work on weaknesses honestly.
Frequently asked questions
How often should we run a manager effectiveness survey?
Run a manager effectiveness survey once or twice a year. That gives managers time to act on results and show change before the next round. Between surveys, use a short pulse question or two on manager support to track momentum, and re-survey individual managers who are working on a specific development plan.
Should manager survey results affect compensation or promotions?
Most companies keep manager survey results separate from compensation, at least at first, so employees answer honestly and managers treat it as development. Over time, sustained patterns can inform promotion decisions alongside other evidence. If you link them, say so clearly upfront, because it changes how people respond.
What’s the best way to help managers improve after their survey results?
The best way to help managers improve after survey results is ongoing, private support focused on their specific gaps. Blomma gives every manager an AI coach to prepare feedback, plan 1:1s, and handle hard conversations, and it follows up on their development goals, so improvement continues long after the results meeting.
How many responses does a manager need for valid survey results?
A manager typically needs at least three to five responses for results to be shared, both for anonymity and meaningful data. For very small teams, combine results across two survey rounds or report only at a higher level. Always tell employees the minimum threshold before the survey opens.
Can managers see who said what in an upward feedback survey?
Managers shouldn’t be able to see individual responses in an upward feedback survey. Use minimum group sizes, report only aggregated scores, and remove identifying details from comments. If employees suspect answers can be traced, they’ll soften their feedback, and the survey loses its value.
