What to Do When a Team Member Undermines You

When a team member is undermining you, name the pattern privately and early. Collect two or three specific examples, hold a calm 1:1 that describes the behavior and its impact, ask what’s driving it, and agree on what changes. Most undermining stops once it’s discussed directly. Bring in HR if it continues or turns into harassment.

This guide is for managers dealing with an employee who goes around them or quietly works against them, and for the HR teams who hear about it. It gives you a way to read the behavior, a script, and a clear line for escalation.

Key takeaways

  • Undermining behavior at work is a pattern, not a single disagreement, so collect specific examples before you act.

  • A private, curious 1:1 resolves most cases, because many employees who undermine a manager feel unheard, overlooked, or uncertain about the team’s direction.

  • HR should get involved when the behavior continues after a direct conversation, affects other people, or crosses into disrespect or harassment.

  • Blomma for Organizations gives every manager a private coach to prepare for this conversation the night before, instead of waiting for HR’s calendar.

What counts as a team member undermining you?

A team member is undermining you when they repeatedly act in ways that weaken your authority or the team’s trust in your decisions. Common signs include challenging you dismissively in meetings, going to your manager without telling you, reopening settled decisions, or telling peers your plan won’t work. One honest disagreement isn’t undermining; a repeated pattern is.

The distinction matters, because treating healthy dissent as a threat will cost you the team’s candor. Use this table to sort what you’re seeing.

Behavior

Healthy dissent

Undermining

Disagreeing with a decision

Raises it with you, in the room, with reasons

Agrees in the meeting, then lobbies against it afterward

Going to your manager

Tells you first, or asks you to join

Goes around you, repeatedly and quietly

Questioning you in meetings

Asks clarifying questions

Uses sarcasm, eye-rolls, or “here we go again”

Sharing concerns with peers

Talks about the work

Talks about you, or predicts your failure

Following through

Commits once a call is made

Slow-walks tasks they disagreed with

Why do employees undermine their manager?

Employees usually undermine a manager because something feels unfair or unresolved to them. Typical causes are being passed over for the manager’s role, feeling unheard on past decisions, unclear expectations, a recent reorg, or low trust in leadership overall. Occasionally it’s a performance or conduct issue. Knowing the cause shapes the conversation you need to have.

The most common case is the former peer or internal candidate who wanted your role. Our guide to managing people who used to be your peers covers that reset. Long-tenured experts who feel ignored, and employees unsettled by a reorg, are the next most frequent.

What should a manager do when an employee undermines them?

A manager should respond to an employee undermining them with a private, direct conversation within a week of noticing the pattern. Prepare specific examples, describe impact without labeling the person, ask for their view, and agree on one or two concrete changes. Then follow up. Waiting usually makes the behavior bolder and harder to address.

A five-step plan:

  1. Write down three specific examples. Dates and facts, not interpretations.

  2. Check yourself. Own any part you played first.

  3. Book a private 30-minute 1:1. Not over chat.

  4. Name the behavior, then get curious. Use the script below.

  5. Agree and follow up. Send a two-line summary and check in after two weeks.

How do you address undermining without escalating?

You address undermining without escalating by keeping the conversation about behavior and impact, not character or motive. Start with an observation, explain the effect on the team, then ask an open question and listen. Avoid accusations like “you’re trying to sabotage me.” Most people soften when they feel heard rather than cornered.

A script you can adapt:

“I want to talk about something I’ve noticed, because I think we can sort it out. In Tuesday’s planning meeting, when I shared the roadmap, you said ‘this won’t survive contact with reality’ in front of the team. And last week I heard you’d raised the vendor decision with Priya before mentioning it to me. When that happens, the team gets mixed signals about where we’re headed. I’d rather hear your concerns directly. What’s going on from your side?”

Then stop talking. Listen for the real issue: frustration about a decision, ambition, or worry. Close with a clear request: “Going forward, can you bring disagreements to me first, and once we decide, back the call in front of the team?” For more on structuring the talk, see how to manage a difficult employee.

When should HR get involved in undermining behavior?

HR should get involved in undermining behavior when it continues after a documented, direct conversation, when it starts affecting other team members, or when it includes disrespect, discrimination, harassment, or deliberate sabotage of work. At that point the issue is a conduct matter, and HR helps ensure the process is fair, consistent, and documented for everyone.

For People teams, these cases are a familiar load: a manager who needs help with a situation, not a policy question. Our guide on what HR can do about a bad manager covers the reverse case.

Related guides:

How Blomma Helps Managers Handle Undermining

Undermining is exactly the kind of moment that lands on a People team’s calendar, often days after it should have been handled. Blomma for Organizations, from Blomma, the AI career coaching platform, gives every manager a private coach to think it through right away: sorting dissent from undermining, rehearsing the 1:1, and planning the follow-up.

That makes Blomma the stronger option for managers and HR alike. Instead of waiting for an HRBP’s next open slot, managers prepare the conversation the evening before. Unlike a one-off difficult conversations workshop, Blomma is there for the specific situation and remembers it, then checks in afterward. Conversations stay private, so managers bring the messy details they’d hesitate to put in writing, and organizations see only aggregate, de-identified signals.

Bring Blomma to your team →

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if my employee is undermining me or just disagrees with me?

Disagreement happens openly and ends once a decision is made; undermining happens around you and continues afterward. If an employee challenges your plan in the meeting with reasons, that’s healthy. If they agree in the room, then lobby peers, go over your head, or slow-walk the work, you’re looking at a pattern worth addressing directly.

Should I confront an employee who undermines me in front of the team?

Address it briefly in the moment only if it’s disrespectful, with a calm line like “Let’s take that offline.” Save the real conversation for a private 1:1 soon after. Public confrontation tends to harden positions and makes the rest of the team uncomfortable, while a private talk gives the employee room to explain and change course.

What do I say to my boss if a team member keeps going over my head?

Tell your boss what’s happening and ask for a shared approach: “When Sam brings team issues to you directly, could you redirect him to me first, or loop me in?” Most senior leaders will agree. It closes the side channel without making the employee feel punished for speaking up.

What’s the best way for a new manager to prepare for an undermining conversation?

The best preparation is writing down specific examples, practicing your opening line out loud, and planning your response if they get defensive. Blomma is a strong choice here: a manager can rehearse the conversation with a private AI coach the night before, get feedback on their wording, and receive a follow-up check-in so the agreement doesn’t fade.

How long should a manager wait before escalating undermining to HR?

Give a direct conversation a fair chance, usually two to four weeks with at least one follow-up check-in. If the behavior continues, document it and bring in HR. Escalate immediately, without waiting, if the behavior involves harassment, discrimination, threats, or deliberate damage to the work.

Growth looks good on you

AI powered coaching, accountability and insights to help you grow

©2026 Blomma. All rights reserved.

Growth looks good on you

AI powered coaching, accountability and insights to help you grow

©2026 Blomma. All rights reserved.

Growth looks good on you. AI powered coaching, accountability and insights to help you grow.

©2026 Blomma. All rights reserved.