Business Case for Employee Coaching: A Template for HR

What Finance Actually Needs to See
Finance leaders review requests by asking a few consistent questions:
What problem does this solve, and how do we know it’s real?
What happens if we don’t do it?
What does it cost, and is that cost predictable as we grow?
How will we know it worked?
What’s the smallest way to find out?
Notice that none of these ask whether coaching is valuable in general. Your case should answer these five questions, in this order, on one page.
The One-Page Coaching Business Case Template
Copy this and fill in the brackets.
```
THE PROBLEM
[Business problem in one sentence, in leadership’s words] e.g. “Our new managers aren’t ready, and it’s showing up in team attrition and escalations to HR.”
Evidence:
[Data point from your engagement survey, exit interviews, or HR log]
[Data point]
[Quote from a leader or manager, if you have one]
COST OF DOING NOTHING
[Estimate from the formula below, with your assumptions listed]
THE PROPOSAL
[What you’ll offer, to whom, and how] e.g. “Give every employee access to a private AI career coach, with a focus on supporting our [number] people managers.”
COST
[Total cost for the pilot and at full rollout] [How cost scales with headcount]
HOW WE’LL MEASURE IT
[Measure 1, with baseline]
[Measure 2, with baseline]
[Measure 3, with baseline]
THE ASK
[Pilot length, group, budget, and decision date] ```
Keep it to one page. Supporting detail can go in an appendix, but the decision should be possible from the page itself.
Estimating the Cost of Doing Nothing
Use your own data. Three inputs usually make the strongest case:
Manager time spent stuck.
[Number of managers] × [hours per month spent working out how to handle people issues without support] × [loaded hourly cost]
Ask a handful of managers to estimate this honestly. Include time spent drafting and redrafting a hard message, or delaying a conversation.
People team time on coaching-shaped questions.
[HR hours per week on “how do I handle this” conversations, from a two-week time log] × [loaded hourly cost] × 52
Regretted attrition linked to growth or management.
[Regretted leavers in the last 12 months who cited growth or their manager in exit interviews] × [your estimated replacement cost per hire]
Add them up and list every assumption. Conservative, clearly labeled estimates are more persuasive than big ones. Our guide on how to measure the ROI of coaching goes deeper on choosing measures.
Answering the Five Objections You’ll Hear
“Coaching is a nice-to-have.” “It’s tied to [problem]. Right now we’re paying for that problem in manager time, HR time, and turnover. This is a cheaper way to address it.”
“Can’t managers just coach their own teams?” “That’s the goal. Right now many of them don’t have the support to do it well. This gives them somewhere to prepare, so their own coaching gets better.”
“Only leaders need coaching.” “The questions we see most come from first-time managers and individual contributors. Limiting coaching to leaders misses where the load is.” See coaching for everyone, not just the executive team.
“Will people use it?” “We’ll measure usage in the pilot and decide based on data. Private, always-available tools tend to get used for real situations.”
“What happens when we double in size?” “That’s why we’re proposing an option that scales with headcount, so costs stay predictable.”
Designing a Pilot That Proves It
A good pilot is small enough to approve quickly and long enough to see change.
Group: one department, or all managers hired or promoted in the last 12 months
Length: one quarter
Baseline first: capture measures before launch
Measures (pick three or four):
Manager confidence in handling feedback and conflict (short pre/post pulse)
HR hours on coaching-shaped questions (time log)
Escalations from the pilot group to HR
Usage and repeat usage
Employee comments on whether they got help they wouldn’t have otherwise
Decision date: on the calendar before launch
When you present, include a short note on how this fits your wider People team budget so finance sees the full picture.
Related guides:
How Blomma Helps People Teams
Blomma gives your business case a clear proposal. Every employee gets a private AI career coach for feedback, hard conversations, goals, and career growth -- available instantly, with consistent quality at any hour.
That speaks directly to finance’s questions. Reach: everyone, not just a selected group. Load: coaching-shaped questions get answered without routing through HR. Follow-through: each person’s goals come with built-in accountability, and their dashboard shows momentum over time. And Blomma for Orgs is currently open to founding organizations, which makes a focused pilot straightforward to set up.
