Coaching Employees to Improve Performance

Coaching vs. Managing Performance
Managing performance is about setting expectations and holding people to them. Coaching is about helping someone find their own way to meet those expectations. You need both.
The difference shows up in how you talk. A managing conversation says, “This report needs to be done by Friday with no errors.” A coaching conversation adds, “What’s getting in the way of that? What would help?” The expectation stays firm; the path gets built together. People are far more committed to plans they helped create.
Diagnose the Cause: The Four-Box Check
Before your first conversation, think through which of these is most likely. Then test your guess by asking.
Cause | Sounds like | What helps |
|---|---|---|
Clarity | “I didn’t realize that was the priority.” | Specific expectations and examples of good work |
Skill | “I’m not sure how to do this well.” | Training, pairing, practice, feedback loops |
Motivation | “I don’t see why it matters.” | Connection to purpose, career goals, recognition |
Obstacles | “I keep getting pulled onto other things.” | Removing blockers, adjusting workload, support |
Many gaps are a mix. A common one: unclear expectations that turned into low motivation after a few rounds of critical feedback. Fixing clarity first often fixes the rest.
The Four-Conversation Coaching Arc
Conversation 1: Name it. Share what you’ve observed, specifically and without judgment. Ask for their view. The goal is shared understanding of the gap, not agreement on everything.
Conversation 2: Understand it. Explore the cause together using the four boxes. Ask what’s working, what’s hard, and what they’d change. Listen more than you talk.
Conversation 3: Plan it. Agree on two or three concrete actions, what support you’ll provide, and how you’ll both know it’s working. Write it down and share it. A simple coaching plan keeps you both honest.
Conversation 4: Check it. Two to four weeks later, review progress against the plan. Recognize what improved. Adjust what didn’t. Repeat the check until the gap closes.
These don’t have to be separate meetings. For a small gap, the first three can happen in one 1:1. For a bigger one, give each its own space.
Twelve Performance Coaching Questions
To open up:
“How do you feel the last few weeks have gone?”
“What’s been the hardest part of [project]?”
“What does great look like to you here?”
To understand:
“What gets in the way when you sit down to do this?”
“Where do you feel most and least confident?”
“What would make this easier?”
To plan:
“What’s one thing you could try this week?”
“What support would help most from me?”
“How will we both know it’s working?”
To check in:
“What changed since we last talked?”
“What surprised you?”
“What do you want to keep doing, and what do you want to adjust?”
A Script for the First Conversation
“I want to talk about [specific area]. Over the last [timeframe], I’ve noticed [specific observation -- e.g., two of the last three client reports went out with errors that needed correcting]. I’d like to understand what’s going on from your side, and figure out together what would help. How does that land with you?”
Then stop talking. Let them respond fully before you share more. If they get defensive, acknowledge it: “I can tell this is frustrating. I’m raising it because I want you to succeed here.” For more on this kind of conversation, see our guide to having a difficult conversation with a direct report.
When to Move Beyond Coaching
Coaching is the right first step for most performance gaps. Move to a more formal process when:
The same gap persists after several check-ins with clear expectations and real support
The issue involves conduct, not performance
The impact on the team or customers is serious
At that point, bring in your HR partner and consider a structured plan. Our guide on handling underperformance on your team walks through the next steps, and coaching can continue alongside any formal plan.
Related guides:
How Blomma Helps People Teams
Performance coaching asks a lot of managers, and many are doing it for the first time. Blomma gives every manager a private AI coach to prepare: diagnose the cause, plan what to say, rehearse a hard opening line, and reflect afterward. It’s there the night before the 1:1, not just in next month’s training.
It helps the employee side too. People can use Blomma to work through feedback, turn it into a plan, and track their goals with built-in accountability. Both sides arrive at the next conversation better prepared, and your People team gets fewer last-minute “how do I handle this?” messages.
